Home

What's the Difference Between Éclairs and Cream Puffs?

The difference between éclairs and cream puffs is mainly their shape and usual topping: éclairs are long pastries, commonly filled with pastry cream and topped with icing, while cream puffs are round and often filled with whipped cream. Both have hollow choux pastry shells, and you can use similar fillings in either, so shape is the most reliable distinction.

How can you tell éclairs and cream puffs apart?

An éclair is long and narrow, with a fairly even width and rounded ends. To make one, you pipe the dough in a straight line, then usually add a smooth strip of glaze across the top after filling.

A cream puff is round with a domed top. You can serve it whole with the filling hidden inside, or slice it across the middle to show a layer of cream beneath its pastry lid.

Shape identifies the pastry more reliably than size or filling. A small, custard-filled round puff is still a cream puff, while a long shell filled with whipped cream is still an éclair. Both come in bite-sized and larger versions, so size alone won't tell you which is which.

Do éclairs and cream puffs use the same pastry?

For both pastries, you use pâte à choux, usually shortened to choux pastry. You make it by heating liquid and butter, stirring in flour to form a cooked paste, then gradually beating in eggs. Recipes may use water, milk or a mixture of the two.

Unlike puff pastry, choux contains no folded layers of butter. You don't need yeast or baking powder: steam expands the moist dough in the oven, creating a cavity while the outside sets into a firm shell.

The baked shell has a thin, crisp exterior and a lightly eggy interior. Recipe differences affect colour, tenderness and crispness, but you don't need a separate dough for each pastry. The way you shape it determines whether you make an éclair or a cream puff.

That shared dough explains why an unfilled éclair shell and an unfilled cream puff taste so similar. Most of the flavour difference comes from what you put inside and on top.

What fillings and toppings do they have?

The familiar chocolate éclair combines a choux shell, vanilla pastry cream and chocolate icing or ganache. Pastry cream is a cooked custard thickened with starch; ganache is a mixture of chocolate and cream that sets into a soft coating.

Cream puffs often contain sweetened whipped cream and have a light dusting of icing sugar. However, fillings aren't fixed rules: you can use pastry cream, whipped cream or mixtures of the two in either shape.

  • Pastry cream gives either pastry a smooth, substantial filling that holds its shape well.
  • Sweetened whipped cream gives you a lighter, airier bite with a fresh dairy flavour.
  • Diplomat cream, made by folding whipped cream into pastry cream, combines a custard flavour with a softer texture.
  • Chocolate, coffee, fruit or nut flavours can change the filling or topping without changing which pastry you're making.

Some cream puffs have craquelin, a thin disc of butter, sugar and flour that you place over the dough before baking. It forms a crisp, crackled cap. This topping doesn't turn the puff into an éclair, just as adding chocolate to a round puff doesn't make it an éclair.

Which tastes richer, an éclair or a cream puff?

A typical glazed éclair tastes sweeter and more substantial than a cream puff filled only with lightly sweetened whipped cream. The custard adds density, while the icing contributes another layer of sweetness and flavour.

That comparison changes with the recipe. A large cream puff packed with chocolate pastry cream can feel richer than a small éclair with a lightly sweetened filling. Choose by filling and topping, rather than assuming one pastry is always lighter.

Freshness also affects texture. With either pastry, you should notice some contrast between shell and filling, although the shell gradually softens as it absorbs moisture. A cream puff with craquelin may retain a noticeable sugary crunch even after its inner shell becomes tender.

Can you bake both from one batch?

You can divide one batch of choux dough between éclairs and cream puffs. The main differences are how you pipe the dough and how you judge when the shells are done; different shapes and sizes may not finish baking at the same time.

  1. Pipe straight, even lengths for éclairs and rounded mounds for cream puffs, leaving room for expansion.
  2. Gently smooth pointed tips with a damp fingertip so they don't burn before the shells finish baking.
  3. Follow a tested recipe's oven settings, and avoid opening the door early while the shells are still setting.
  4. Bake until the shells are well browned and firm, not merely puffed and pale, then follow the recipe's drying instructions.
  5. Let the shells cool completely before adding cream or custard, then add your topping.

You'll need to pipe éclairs more precisely if you want straight, evenly shaped shells. Round puffs are generally more forgiving for a first attempt. Fill either through small holes with a piping bag, or cut the shells open if you prefer a visible filling.

How should you store éclairs and cream puffs?

Fill just before serving for the crispest shells. Keep fully cooled, unfilled shells in an airtight container for short-term storage, or freeze them for later use. If they soften, briefly crisp them up in the oven and let them cool completely before filling.

Refrigerate pastries containing custard or whipped cream. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration recommends keeping refrigerated foods at 40°F (4°C) or below and limiting time at room temperature to two hours, or one hour above 90°F (32°C).

Keep filled pastries covered without pressing against their tops, and follow any storage instructions supplied with purchased pastries. For homemade versions, plan to serve them the day you fill them for the best texture. Refrigeration protects perishable fillings, but it won't preserve the shell's original crispness.

Sources